All notes

Paid Media

What premium D2C brands do differently with ad creative

14 January 2025

2 min read

One of the consistent differences I've noticed between brands that maintain strong margins at scale and those that don't is how they approach creative.

Most brands treat creative as a production task: brief the agency or creator, get the assets, upload them to the ad platform, and move on. Premium brands treat creative as a strategic function that requires the same analytical rigor as campaign structure or audience targeting.

Specifically, the brands that do this well: test hypotheses rather than just testing ads, understand which creative elements drive which outcomes, build a library of winning frameworks rather than starting from scratch each cycle, and have a clear brand voice that makes their ads recognizable even without a logo.

Creative at this level isn't just about aesthetics. It's about understanding your customer well enough to make something that feels true to their experience — and that's a marketing problem as much as it is a creative one.

The practical takeaway: start treating your creative briefs like performance hypotheses. 'We think showing the product in context X will perform better than product on white background because of reason Y.' Test it, measure it, and build a library of what works. That's how you stop starting from scratch every quarter.